Best Crumbl Cookie Flavors, Ranked by Customer Ratings (2026)

Quick answer: Based on Crumbl’s own customer ratings, the best Crumbl flavor is the Biscoff® Pie (4.75 stars from 32,232 reviews). The best-rated cookie is the Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunk Cookie (4.67 stars from 645,628 reviews), and the most-reviewed flavor of all time is the Milk Chocolate Chip Cookie (792,055 reviews).

We ranked 481 Crumbl flavors using the star ratings on Crumbl’s official flavor pages, nearly 20 million reviews in total. Here’s the top 25, the best cookies, brownies, cheesecakes, cakes and pies, the most popular picks and the lowest-rated flavors.

Crumbl Biscoff Pie

How We Ranked Crumbl Flavors

Crumbl customers rate every flavor they try, and each flavor page on crumblcookies.com shows its average star rating and total number of reviews. We collected the ratings for all 481 rated Crumbl flavors, which add up to about 19.7 million reviews.

  • Minimum reviews: to keep the rankings fair, the main lists only include flavors with at least 10,000 reviews (334 flavors qualify). A brand-new flavor with a few hundred five-star reviews can’t jump to the top.
  • Ties: when two flavors have the same rating, the one with more reviews ranks higher.
  • All desserts count: Crumbl sells cookies, brownies, cakes, cheesecakes, pies and cups, so the overall top 25 includes all of them. There’s a cookies-only list below too.
  • Ratings move: scores change as new reviews come in, and most flavors rotate, so a flavor on this list may not be on the menu this week.

Across all flavors, the average Crumbl rating is 4.40 stars. 102 flavors score 4.50 or higher, and 68 score below 4.00.

Top 25 Best Crumbl Flavors of All Time

#FlavorRatingReviewsType
1Biscoff® Pie4.75 ★32,232Pie
2Dubai-Style Chocolate Brownie4.69 ★11,113Brownie
3Strawberry Heart Cake4.68 ★31,058Cake
4Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunk Cookie4.67 ★645,628Cookie
5Classic Cheesecake4.67 ★30,454Cheesecake
6Triple Berry Shortcake4.67 ★12,458Cake
7Dubai-Style Chocolate Strawberry Brownie4.66 ★43,030Brownie
8Biscoff® Skillet Cookie4.66 ★19,414Cookie
9Valentine’s Cake Batter Cookie4.66 ★18,351Cookie
10Dubai-Style Chocolate Cookie4.65 ★82,245Cookie
11Vanilla Bean Strawberry Cake4.65 ★26,488Cake
12Dubai-Style Chocolate Strawberry Cup4.63 ★21,070Cup
13Dubai-Style Chocolate Sandwich Cookie4.63 ★20,536Cookie
14Pink Velvet Heart Cake4.63 ★13,064Cake
15Tres Leches Cake4.62 ★171,009Cake
16Double Chocolate Chip Cookie4.62 ★80,039Cookie
17Strawberry Tres Leches Cake4.62 ★29,996Cake
18St. Patrick’s Cake Batter Cookie4.62 ★15,646Cookie
19Cookies & Cream Pie4.61 ★53,345Pie
20Strawberry Cake4.61 ★34,532Cake
21Yellow Sheet Cake4.61 ★12,640Cake
22Cake Batter Cookie4.60 ★130,878Cookie
23Strawberry Cheesecake4.60 ★76,004Cheesecake
24Chocolate Chip Cookie Thins (Set of 2)4.60 ★48,390Cookie
25Pumpkin Spice Sheet Cake4.60 ★21,131Cake

Only 9 of the top 25 are cookies. Crumbl’s cakes, brownies, cheesecakes and pies score especially well, and Dubai-style chocolate desserts take five of the top 13 spots.

The Top 10 Crumbl Flavors, Explained

1. Biscoff® Pie (4.75 ★)

Crumbl Biscoff Pie

32,232 reviews · Pie. Biscoff® cream cheese filling on a crunchy Biscoff® crust, topped with a pool of Biscoff® spread, whipped cream and a whole Biscoff® cookie. It’s the only Crumbl flavor with 10,000+ reviews to reach 4.75 stars.

2. Dubai-Style Chocolate Brownie (4.69 ★)

Crumbl Dubai-Style Chocolate Brownie

11,113 reviews · Brownie. A fudgy brownie with a crunchy kataifi and pistachio filling, a layer of milk chocolate and a drizzle of pistachio cream. It’s also on Crumbl’s own list of its 25 most popular flavors. See the full Dubai-Style Chocolate Brownie guide.

3. Strawberry Heart Cake (4.68 ★)

Crumbl Strawberry Heart Cake

31,058 reviews · Cake. A heart-shaped strawberry cake with a swirl of strawberry cream cheese frosting, made with Crumbl’s house-made strawberry jam. It’s the highest-rated cake in our rankings. See the full Strawberry Heart Cake guide.

4. Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunk Cookie (4.67 ★)

Crumbl Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunk Cookie

645,628 reviews · Cookie. A classic cookie loaded with semi-sweet chocolate chunks and finished with flaky sea salt. With 645,628 reviews, no other flavor keeps a rating this high with so many votes. See the full Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunk Cookie guide.

5. Classic Cheesecake (4.67 ★)

Crumbl Classic Cheesecake

30,454 reviews · Cheesecake. A New York-style cheesecake on a graham cracker crust, topped with fresh strawberries. It’s the best-rated Crumbl cheesecake.

6. Triple Berry Shortcake (4.67 ★)

Crumbl Triple Berry Shortcake

12,458 reviews · Cake. Two layers of vanilla shortcake stacked with fresh whipped cream and house-made triple berry jam.

7. Dubai-Style Chocolate Strawberry Brownie (4.66 ★)

Crumbl Dubai-Style Chocolate Strawberry Brownie

43,030 reviews · Brownie. The Dubai-style brownie with kataifi, pistachio filling and milk chocolate, plus slices of fresh strawberries on top.

8. Biscoff® Skillet Cookie (4.66 ★)

Crumbl Biscoff Skillet Cookie

19,414 reviews · Cookie. A lightly spiced Biscoff® cookie topped with fluffy mousse, Biscoff® cookie pieces and a drizzle of melted Biscoff®. See the full Biscoff® Skillet Cookie guide.

9. Valentine’s Cake Batter Cookie (4.66 ★)

Crumbl Valentine’s Cake Batter Cookie

18,351 reviews · Cookie. A cake batter cookie with cake batter cream cheese frosting and heart sprinkles. It’s a Valentine’s version of the Cake Batter Cookie, which also makes the top 25.

10. Dubai-Style Chocolate Cookie (4.65 ★)

Crumbl Dubai-Style Chocolate Cookie

82,245 reviews · Cookie. A rich brownie cookie with crunchy kataifi and pistachio filling, milk chocolate and pistachio cream. With 82,245 reviews, it’s the most-reviewed flavor in the top 10 after the Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunk.

Best Crumbl Cookies (Cookies Only)

If you only want cookies, these are the 15 highest-rated Crumbl cookies with at least 10,000 reviews:

#CookieRatingReviews
1Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunk Cookie4.67 ★645,628
2Biscoff® Skillet Cookie4.66 ★19,414
3Valentine’s Cake Batter Cookie4.66 ★18,351
4Dubai-Style Chocolate Cookie4.65 ★82,245
5Dubai-Style Chocolate Sandwich Cookie4.63 ★20,536
6Double Chocolate Chip Cookie4.62 ★80,039
7St. Patrick’s Cake Batter Cookie4.62 ★15,646
8Cake Batter Cookie4.60 ★130,878
9Chocolate Chip Cookie Thins (Set of 2)4.60 ★48,390
10Milk Chocolate Chip Cookie4.59 ★792,055
11Brookies & Cream Cookie ft. OREO®4.59 ★27,216
12Strawberry Biscoff® Cookie4.59 ★12,311
13Brownie Batter Cookie4.58 ★327,243
14Peanut Butter Cup Skillet Cookie ft. REESE’S4.58 ★48,979
15Strawberry Skillet Cookie4.58 ★31,552

Chocolate chip cookies are the safest pick at Crumbl. The Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunk, Double Chocolate Chip, Chocolate Chip Cookie Thins and Milk Chocolate Chip all score 4.59 or higher, and the cake batter cookies aren’t far behind.

Best Crumbl Desserts by Type

Best Crumbl Brownies

#BrownieRatingReviews
1Dubai-Style Chocolate Brownie4.69 ★11,113
2Dubai-Style Chocolate Strawberry Brownie4.66 ★43,030
3Chocolate Peanut Butter Brownie ft. REESE’S PIECES4.56 ★17,743
4Biscoff® Crunch Brownie4.53 ★32,215
5Peanut Butter Cup Brownie ft. REESE’S4.51 ★40,862

Best Crumbl Cheesecakes

#CheesecakeRatingReviews
1Classic Cheesecake4.67 ★30,454
2Strawberry Cheesecake4.60 ★76,004
3Raspberry Cheesecake4.57 ★85,844
4Cinnamon Roll Cheesecake4.57 ★19,816
5Cherry Cheesecake4.57 ★10,598

Best Crumbl Cakes

#CakeRatingReviews
1Strawberry Heart Cake4.68 ★31,058
2Triple Berry Shortcake4.67 ★12,458
3Vanilla Bean Strawberry Cake4.65 ★26,488
4Pink Velvet Heart Cake4.63 ★13,064
5Tres Leches Cake4.62 ★171,009

Best Crumbl Pies

#PieRatingReviews
1Biscoff® Pie4.75 ★32,232
2Cookies & Cream Pie4.61 ★53,345
3Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie ft. OREO® x REESE’S4.60 ★20,740
4Lemon Pie4.59 ★21,074
5Cookie Dough Pie4.56 ★18,305

Best Crumbl Cups and Other Treats

#DessertRatingReviews
1Dubai-Style Chocolate Strawberry Cup4.63 ★21,070
2Cookies & Cream Cocoa Cup4.60 ★19,516
3Berry Trifle Cake Cup4.56 ★43,063
4Pumpkin Square4.56 ★36,071
5Brownie Dippers4.49 ★15,129

Most Popular Crumbl Cookies (Most Reviewed)

Review count is the best public sign of how many people have bought a flavor. These are the 10 most-reviewed Crumbl flavors of all time, and all of them are cookies:

#FlavorReviewsRating
1Milk Chocolate Chip Cookie792,0554.59 ★
2Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunk Cookie645,6284.67 ★
3Brownie Batter Cookie327,2434.58 ★
4S’mores Cookie280,3084.48 ★
5Cookies & Cream Cookie264,8844.56 ★
6Pink Sugar Cookie263,7594.48 ★
7Pink Velvet Cake Cookie212,9554.48 ★
8Churro Cookie203,4854.52 ★
9Cookies & Cream Milkshake Cookie ft. MINI OREO®186,9154.43 ★
10Classic Pink Sugar Cookie185,7494.19 ★

Popular doesn’t always mean top-rated. The Classic Pink Sugar Cookie has 185,749 reviews but only 4.19 stars, while the Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunk Cookie is both hugely popular and one of the best-rated flavors Crumbl has ever sold.

Crumbl’s Own Top 25 vs. Customer Ratings

Crumbl publishes its own Top 25 Crumbl flavors list based on its most popular picks. When you check those picks against customer ratings, the highest-rated are the Dubai-Style Chocolate Brownie (4.69), Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunk Cookie (4.67), Milk Chocolate Chip Cookie (4.59), Brownie Batter Cookie (4.58) and S’mores Skillet Cookie ft. HERSHEY’S (4.57). The lowest-rated picks on Crumbl’s list are the French Toast Cookie (4.29) and Banana Pudding (4.31). Only two of Crumbl’s picks make our top 25.

Best Crumbl Classic Flavors

Crumbl’s two classic flavors are on the menu every week. Here’s how they rate:

Classic flavorRatingReviews
Chocolate Chip Cookie4.70 ★2,865
Pink Sugar Cookie4.48 ★263,759

The Chocolate Chip Cookie has the higher score, but it has fewer than 3,000 reviews so far, so it doesn’t meet our 10,000-review cutoff yet. Crumbl has sold several chocolate chip cookies over the years, and they all rate well: the Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunk (4.67), Double Chocolate Chip (4.62) and Milk Chocolate Chip (4.59).

Lowest-Rated Crumbl Flavors

These are the 10 lowest-rated Crumbl flavors with at least 2,000 reviews:

#FlavorRatingReviews
1Tangy Mango Cookie ft. Tajín®2.81 ★3,979
2Flamin’ Lime Crunch Cookie2.95 ★4,300
3Chocolate Malt Cookie ft. Tootsie Roll®3.19 ★3,553
4Almost Everything Bagel Cookie3.23 ★6,059
5Strawberry Limeade Cookie ft. NERDS®3.27 ★4,815
6Eggnog Cookie3.40 ★2,737
7Chocolate Caramel Cookie3.43 ★13,337
8Texas Sheet Cake Cookie3.43 ★7,600
9Peach Sugar Cookie3.43 ★4,108
10Cotton Candy Cookie3.45 ★21,222

The lowest-rated flavors are mostly experiments: spicy, savory, candy and drink-inspired cookies. The Tangy Mango Cookie ft. Tajín® and Flamin’ Lime Crunch Cookie are the only two Crumbl flavors rated below 3 stars. Even so, every flavor has fans, so a low score doesn’t mean you won’t love it.

What the Highest-Rated Crumbl Flavors Have in Common

  • Dubai-style chocolate: the brownie, strawberry brownie, cookie, strawberry cup and sandwich cookie all rate 4.63 or higher.
  • Biscoff®: the Biscoff® Pie is #1, the Biscoff® Skillet Cookie is #8, and the Strawberry Biscoff® Cookie and Biscoff® Cake both score 4.58 or higher.
  • Strawberry desserts: five strawberry cakes and cheesecakes make the top 25.
  • Simple classics: chocolate chip and cake batter cookies score about 4.6 or higher.
  • Rich, creamy desserts: cheesecakes, tres leches cakes and cream pies show up again and again near the top.

How to Get Your Favorite Crumbl Flavor Back

  • Vote in the Crumbl App: Crumbl’s Flavor Requests feature lets you vote for (or against) flavors, including ones still in development.
  • Customer Picks: Crumbl Rewards members with Silver status or higher can vote for flavors that return for one day on the third Wednesday of each month.
  • Check the secret menu: many stores bring back past favorites as Hometown Picks. See our Crumbl secret menu page.
  • Watch the weekly lineup: check this week’s Crumbl menu and the next week’s Crumbl menu for returning flavors.

Best Crumbl Flavors FAQs

What is the best Crumbl cookie flavor?

Based on Crumbl’s customer ratings, the best Crumbl flavor overall is the Biscoff® Pie (4.75 stars from 32,232 reviews). The best-rated cookie is the Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunk Cookie (4.67 stars from 645,628 reviews).

What are the top 10 best Crumbl cookies?

Among cookies with 10,000+ reviews: Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunk, Biscoff® Skillet, Valentine’s Cake Batter, Dubai-Style Chocolate, Dubai-Style Chocolate Sandwich, Double Chocolate Chip, St. Patrick’s Cake Batter, Cake Batter, Chocolate Chip Cookie Thins and Milk Chocolate Chip.

What is the most popular Crumbl cookie?

The Milk Chocolate Chip Cookie is the most-reviewed Crumbl flavor with 792,055 reviews, followed by the Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunk Cookie with 645,628.

Which Crumbl cookie has the highest rating?

Among flavors with at least 10,000 reviews, the Biscoff® Pie has the highest rating at 4.75 stars. Among cookies only, the Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunk Cookie leads with 4.67 stars.

What is the worst-rated Crumbl cookie?

The Tangy Mango Cookie ft. Tajín® has the lowest rating at 2.81 stars, followed by the Flamin’ Lime Crunch Cookie at 2.95. They are the only two Crumbl flavors rated below 3 stars.

What is the best Crumbl brownie?

The Dubai-Style Chocolate Brownie is the highest-rated Crumbl brownie at 4.69 stars, followed by the Dubai-Style Chocolate Strawberry Brownie at 4.66.

What is the best Crumbl cheesecake?

The Classic Cheesecake is the best-rated Crumbl cheesecake at 4.67 stars, followed by the Strawberry Cheesecake at 4.60.

Is the Crumbl Pink Sugar Cookie good?

Yes. The Pink Sugar Cookie has 4.48 stars from 263,759 reviews, which makes it one of the most-reviewed Crumbl flavors ever.

How many Crumbl flavors are there?

Crumbl’s website has pages for 485 flavors, and 481 of them have customer ratings. Most flavors rotate, so only a handful are on the menu each week.

How are Crumbl flavors rated?

Customers rate the desserts they buy, and Crumbl shows each flavor’s average star rating and review count on its flavor pages. Ratings update as new reviews come in.

How can I find the best Crumbl flavor this week?

Check our This Week Crumbl Menu page, which lists the current lineup with each flavor’s rating.

Related Crumbl Guides

Similar Posts